Reconsidering The Pilgrims, Piety And America's Founding Principles

Nov 26, 2015
Originally published on November 26, 2015 7:36 pm

The Pilgrims are among the early heroes of American history, celebrated every Thanksgiving for their perseverance in the New World against great odds.

To Christian conservatives, they are role models for another reason as well: They were deeply committed to their Christian faith and not afraid to say so.

In the Mayflower Compact, the governing document signed shortly before the Pilgrims disembarked in Massachusetts' Provincetown Harbor, Pilgrim leaders said they undertook their voyage across the Atlantic "for the glory of God and the advancement of the Christian faith."

Some Christian activists cite that declaration as evidence for their claim that America was founded as a Christian nation, notwithstanding the fact that the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution were written more than 150 years later and incorporated a much broader variety of early American views.

Puncturing Myths About The Pilgrims

In countless retellings over the past 400 years, the Pilgrim story has become part of American mythology, and fact has not always been separated clearly from fiction. The Pilgrims, a new PBS film released in time for the Thanksgiving holiday, attempts to set the record straight.

"Our aim is just to say, 'Hey, what really happened?'" says Ric Burns, who wrote and directed the film. "What made the Old World intolerable to these people who came over? What did they believe? What happened to them along the way? How were they transformed by the extreme nature of the experience they had?"

Viewers are reminded that much of what we know about the Pilgrims comes from the written recollection of their most famous governor, William Bradford. Portions of his account are read in the film by the actor Roger Rees.

The description of the settlers as "pilgrims" comes from Bradford himself, who recalled lines from Hebrews 11. "They desired a better country," Bradford wrote, "a heavenly one, wherefore God was not ashamed to be called their God."

It is from Bradford's account, narrated in the PBS film, that we know about the cruelty of the Pilgrims' first few months in the New World, when half of the settlers died from starvation or disease.

"It was winter, and they that know the winters of that country know them to be sharp and harsh," according to Bradford's account. "What could they see but a hideous, desolate wilderness, full of wild beasts and wild men?"

In his film, Burns punctures some of the myths associated with the Pilgrims. They made peace with some of the Indians they encountered, but they slaughtered others. They were devout, but they weren't exactly proponents of religious freedom: People who didn't accept their strict beliefs were expelled from their community.

'Advancement Of The Christian Faith'

It is clear, however, that the Pilgrims leaders set up their colony with the intent that it be governed by biblical principles, as evidenced by the Mayflower Compact. David Barton, an evangelical whose references to history have won him attention in conservative Republican circles, has often cited the Pilgrims' dedication in the Mayflower Compact to "the advancement of the Christian faith."

"It says those people came here to propagate the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ," Barton said a speech available online. "That was their goal, and that's what they were gonna pursue in America."

Secular historians, he continued, have downplayed that reference.

"We're talking about a government document here with a lot of evangelical language in it," he declared. "Most people today are willing to concede that religion is OK if you keep it in private. Keep it at home or keep it at church, but ... you don't want it at school. You don't want it in the courthouse. ... Those aspects of our heritage that are religious and also show public religious expression, we pretty much ignore today."

In an interview with NPR, Barton says the Pilgrims' story makes clear that America was founded as a Bible-based Christian nation.

"If you look back at the Pilgrims, they gave us private property out of the Bible," he says. "They gave us civil rights out of the Bible. They gave us elected government out of the Bible. You'd have to say, a lot of [our heritage] was shaped by biblical principles, and that's why the courts said we're a Christian nation."

Barton is quoting an 1892 Supreme Court ruling that includes a reference to "a mass of organic utterances that this is a Christian nation."

'One Little Pocket Of Colonial America'

Historians, however, have disputed the extent to which the Pilgrims can be counted as among America's founding fathers.

"This is one little pocket of colonial America," says John Fea of Messiah College in Mechanicsburg, Penn. He has written widely on America's early religious history.

"It's hard to make the same argument if you're studying Virginia or Pennsylvania or the Carolinas or Georgia," Fea says. "We've taken that New England model and extrapolated from it over the last 200 or 300 years into some kind of view of the nation as a whole."

Fea notes the absence of any reference to the Bible in either the Declaration of Independence or the U.S. Constitution.

"There are a lot of arguments that say, 'This was just in the air. The Bible would have influenced their construction, even though it's never mentioned,'" he says. "But as a historian, I need a smoking gun. Maybe they left it out because they deliberately wanted to leave it out."

As for the Pilgrims, the PBS film shows their history to be turbulent and often messy.

"Let me tell you," says Burns. "This is more like Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness in many ways than it is like, 'Let's all sit down for turkey for Thanksgiving.'"

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

The tale of the pilgrims has been part of American mythology for a long time. Coming over on the Mayflower, setting up a colony nearly 400 years ago - that story has taken on new meaning lately among conservative Christians. NPR's Tom Gjelten reports that evangelicals highlight the pilgrims determination to be guided by the Bible.

TOM GJELTEN, BYLINE: The pilgrim story is one of the most dramatic in U.S. history, and it's irresistible for filmmakers.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "THE PILGRIMS")

UNIDENTIFIED NARRATOR: September 6, 1620, an aging 180-ton ship called the Mayflower weighed anchor off Plymouth, off the south coast of England and set out on her own across the North Atlantic.

GJELTEN: The pilgrim tale is retold in a new PBS film released in time for this Thanksgiving holiday. Viewers are reminded that much of what we know about the pilgrims comes from the written recollections of their most famous governor, William Bradford.

(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, "THE PILGRIMS")

UNIDENTIFIED NARRATOR: It was winter. And they that know the winters of that country know them to be sharp and harsh. What could they see but a hideous, desolate wilderness full of wild beasts and wild men?

GJELTEN: The pilgrims' perseverance in the face of great odds made them American heroes. But it's the story of the pilgrims' deep faith that interests Christian activists. They often highlight the Mayflower Compact, the document that set forth the pilgrims' political views. They were religious separatists fleeing persecution. And in that compact, they said they undertook their voyage for the glory of God and the advancement of the Christian faith. David Barton, an evangelical prominent in conservative Republican circles, often cites that phrase in his speeches, arguing that secular historians downplay the Mayflower compact because they don't like what it says.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

DAVID BARTON: Do you know what the Mayflower Compact says? It says those people came here to propagate the gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ. That was their goal. That's what they were going to pursue in America. Now, the problem with that is we're talking about a government document here with a lot of evangelical language in it.

GJELTEN: It's an example, Barton said in that speech, that shows that religious expression in America's earliest days was not kept out of public life like it is today. For evangelical conservatives, that's an important point in the debate over what religious practices should be allowed in the public arena these days. In an interview with NPR, Barton said the pilgrims' story makes clear America was founded as a Bible-based, Christian nation.

BARTON: They gave us private property out of the Bible. They gave us civil rights out of the Bible. They gave us elected government out of the Bible. You'd have to say, you know, a lot of this was shaped by biblical principles. And that's why the court said we're a Christian nation.

GJELTEN: He's referring to an 1892 Supreme Court opinion. But John Fea, a specialist in early American religious history at Messiah College, is wary of using the pilgrims' story to argue that America originated as a Christian nation or even that the founders of the nation were inspired by the Bible in writing the Constitution.

JOHN FEA: There's a lot of arguments out there that say, well, this was just in the air, right? The Bible would have influenced their construction of this even though it's never mentioned. You know, for me as a historian, I need a smoking gun. Maybe they just left it out because they deliberately wanted to leave it out, and there were conscious efforts to do so.

GJELTEN: Ric Burns, who wrote and directed the new PBS film, says his goal was to lay out the genuine pilgrim story.

RIC BURNS: Our aim is just to say, hey, what really happened? What made the old world intolerable to these people who came over? What did they believe? What happened to them along the way? And let me tell you, this is more like Joseph Conrad's "Heart Of Darkness" in many ways than it is, like, let's all sit down for turkey for Thanksgiving.

GJELTEN: Indeed, Burns punctures some myths. The pilgrims made peace with some of the Indians they encountered, but they slaughtered others. They were devout, but they weren't exactly proponents of religious freedom. People who didn't accept their strict beliefs were expelled from their community. In some ways, they weren't good early-American models. But American history is full of contradictions. The pilgrim experience is one part of our national origin, along with all the other stories that make up our heritage. Tom Gjelten, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.